The 30-Second Exam Hall Shortcut: ⚡ The 2p Interelectronic Repulsion Anomaly
Chlorine beats Fluorine in electron gain enthalpy due to compact 2p crowding in F!
Step-by-Step Rigorous Workflow & Mathematical Proof
Definition of Electron Gain Enthalpy
Electron gain enthalpy (Δ_eg H) is the enthalpy change when an isolated gaseous atom in its ground state gains an electron to form a gaseous uninegative ion. For halogens, this process is highly exothermic.
- • Negative Δ_eg H indicates energy release.
- • Trend question compares magnitude (exothermicity).
Explain the Fluorine-Chlorine Anomaly
Although electronegativity decreases uniformly from F to I, the electron gain enthalpy of fluorine is unexpectedly less negative than that of chlorine. In fluorine (n=2), the incoming electron enters the compact 2p subshell where it experiences strong repulsive forces from the other seven valence electrons. In chlorine (n=3), the incoming electron enters the larger 3p subshell where interelectronic repulsions are substantially weaker.
- • Δ_eg H of Cl = -349 kJ mol⁻¹.
- • Δ_eg H of F = -328 kJ mol⁻¹.
Establish the Complete Halogen Series
Beyond chlorine, as we descend to bromine and iodine, the increase in atomic size and nuclear shielding causes electron affinity to steadily decrease.
- • Trend: Cl > F > Br > I.
- • Matches Option (3).
360° Option Elimination Engine Key Feature
Diagnose every choice: Know exactly why the right option works and why distractors fail.
Incorrect. This is the trend for electronegativity, but fails for electron gain enthalpy due to the 2p repulsion anomaly.
Incorrect. Bromine does not have a higher electron affinity than chlorine.
Scientifically accurate, reflecting the standard NCERT anomalous halogen order.
Incorrect. Completely inverted order.
NTA Trap Alert: Confusing Electronegativity with Electron Gain Enthalpy
Electronegativity measures bonded atom attraction (F > Cl > Br > I). Electron gain enthalpy measures isolated gaseous ion formation, where chlorine wins because fluorine is too tightly packed.
Core NEET Syllabus Standard
"Interelectronic repulsions in the small 2p subshell make Δ_eg H of fluorine less negative than that of chlorine."